Thrift & Antique Shop
There is always something new to discover at Graymoor’s “That Nothing Be Lost” Thrift & Antique Shop. Located at Graymoor in Garrison, NY, our thrift and antique shop is filled with vintage finds, furniture, artwork, jewelry, collectibles, clothing, housewares, seasonal items and plenty of unexpected treasures.
Whether you come looking for something specific or simply enjoy the treasure hunt, take your time and explore. You never quite know what you’ll find.
COME EXPLORE
We are open Wednesday through Sunday from 10:00am – 5:00pm.
Browse, take your time and see what you discover. Every purchase supports St. Christopher’s Inn and our recovery community.
Featured in
That Nothing Be Lost was featured by The Good Newsroom in a recent article, showcasing the store as a unique local spot for one-of-a-kind gifts and treasures just in time for the holiday shopping season.
Originally published in The Good Newsroom, November 9, 2026

SHOP WITH A GREATER PURPOSE
Everything at That Nothing Be Lost comes from donated merchandise, and proceeds from the store support St. Christopher’s Inn and our mission of helping men overcome substance use disorder.
For some men continuing their recovery at San Damiano House, the store also provides opportunities to build confidence and practical skills through experiences such as assisting customers, organizing merchandise and helping with the everyday needs of the shop.

We especially love discovering TikTok videos from people exploring the store, showing off their favorite finds and sharing the fun of the treasure hunt with others. It has been wonderful to see the enthusiasm for a place that has been part of Graymoor for so many years.
![]() |
![]() |
The “That Nothing Be Lost” Thrift & Antique Shop is located in one of the oldest buildings on the grounds of Graymoor. Constructed in 1916, the gray stone building is located across from St. Christopher’s Inn, and has served in various capacities throughout the years.Today, the building proudly reflects the loving care it has been given since it became the Thrift & Antique Shop. The shop offers four floors of merchandise—from collectibles to necessities; antiques to art selections; everyday items to seasonal bric-a-brac; gently used clothing, shoes, and sports equipment; furniture, glassware and linens—it is a shopper’s paradise.
In addition, the Thrift & Antique Shop provides vocational experience for the St. Christopher’s Inn residents. Whether it is restoring scratched pieces of donated furniture, researching the value of donated items or providing assistance to customers, the Thrift & Antique Shop gives men the opportunity to develop retail skills, to interact with the public and to build their self-esteem.
Due to capacity, a limited number of donations are accepted at any one time. Donors MUST call ahead to schedule a drop off at the Shop at 845-424-3635.Donations are accepted Thursday through Sunday from 10:00 am – 3:00 pm, BY APPOINTMENT.
To make your donation process go smoothly, here are some tips for checking the items you plan to donate:
- Separate clothing into separate bags/boxes from the household items.
- Test electrical equipment and battery-operated items to make sure they work.
- Include all pieces and parts to games, toys and household appliances.
- Please wash clothing before donating.
- Clothing will not be accepted if soiled, stained or ripped.
- Check pockets of clothing for jewelry, money and any other items, and remove them before donating. The Thrift Shop cannot be responsible for returning forgotten items and will consider any such as a donation as well
Donations of new and gently worn men’s clothing and shoes are accepted at the front desk of St. Christopher’s Inn.
- Please wash clothing before donating.
- Clothing will not be accepted if soiled, stained or ripped.
Donations are accepted from 9:00 am – 4:00 pm Monday – Friday.
If you have any questions, please call 845-335-1001.
Store Hours: Wednesday – Sunday, 10-5pmThe following closures will be observed for 2026:
- President’s Day – Monday, February 16
- Holy Thursday – Thursday, April 2
- Good Friday – Friday, April 3
- Ascension – Thursday, May 14
- Memorial Day – Monday, May 25
- Juneteenth – Friday, June 19
- Independence Day Observance – Friday, July 3
- Labor Day – Monday, September 7
- Thanksgiving – Thursday, November 26
- Day After Thanksgiving – Friday, November 27
- Christmas Eve – Thursday, December 24
- Christmas – Friday, December 25
- New Year’s Eve – Thursday, December 31
Additional closures for 2026 coming soon!






